Several popular LGBTQ+ YouTube vloggers have Watch Kalakal Onlineclaimed that YouTube is using the site's "restricted mode" to hide some of their videos.
SEE ALSO: How you can help protect trans kids right nowThe restricted mode for YouTube, according to Google, enables users to filter out "potentially objectionable content," leading some LGBTQ+ vloggers to accuse YouTube of implicitly categorizing their material as not "family-friendly."
That's the complaint British vlogger Rowan Ellis made to Gizmodo, saying, “there is a bias somewhere within that process equating LGBT+ with ‘not family friendly.’”
Ellis posted her own video addressing the issue after she found dozens of her videos fell victim to the process.
In a statement to Gizmodo, YouTube said, “Some videos that cover subjects like health, politics and sexuality may not appear for users and institutions that choose to use this feature.”
Mashablehas also reached out for comment from YouTube.
On Sunday night, the Twitter account for the YouTube Creators page tweeted the following statement that offered a little more detail on the filtering but didn't explain how some of the more innocuous videos that got caught in the filter wound up there.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
But YouTube doesn't appear to have answered the question as to whythese specific videos were flagged. In one such instance, flagged by user NeonFiona, videos about sex and relationships weren't flagged but videos that directly referred to LGBTQ+ issues were.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
And vlogger superstar Tyler Oakley, who has 8 million subscribers, also noted one of his videos was flagged.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
I confirmed that the video he mentions (posted below) does, indeed, get flagged by turning on restricted mode.
The only thing that someone could maybe find objectionable in the video (which is actually a lot of fun and informative) is a naughty word or two. But, as the screenshot below shows, it's not like YouTube is in the habit of filtering out videos with swear words in the title, even in restricted mode.
Additionally, musical duo Tegan & Sara found that several of their music videos disappeared, too, when their page is viewed in restricted mode.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
One of the videos that disappear is the video for "That Girl," which features nothing -- images, lyrics, themes -- that are objectionable for a family audience.
Vloggers are vocalizing their objections and calling on YouTube to offer an explanation that actually lays out specifics as to why the filtering is happening.
until we hear back from @youtube, please actively check on all LGBTQ+ creators you're subscribed to & continue to support their content.
— Tyler Oakley (@tyleroakley) March 19, 2017
In a (yes, restricted) video titled "This Video Is Too Gay For Kids," Calum McSwiggan says he understands why some of his videos that include swearing and more adult content is snagged by the filter but notes other videos that have no questionable content were still filtered.
He specifically notes a video in which he talks about coming out to his grandmother and says, "How on Earth is that not suitable for children? If anything, it would be extremely beneficial and helpful for children to see that, especially children who are struggling to deal with their identity, especially to LGBT+ kids."
It's a well-made and important point, and one that YouTube has yet to adequately answer.
UPDATE (8:50 p.m. ET):Updated to include Tegan and Sara's comment on their music videos as well as YouTue Creator statement.
Topics LGBTQ YouTube
President Trump taken to Walter Reed Medical Center after COVIDJaime Harrison brought a plexiglass divider to debate Lindsey GrahamInstagram attempts to explain 'shadowbanning', but creators still aren't happy'Black Mirror' Season 6 trailer: All the Easter eggs you may have missedKamala Harris reminding Mike Pence 'I'm speaking' is every woman in a meetingBarbie, the only good YouTuber, explains racism in her latest vlogChaos at Twitter as Elon Musk throws employees under the bus to appease rightTrump's Twitter account went on an allHinge and Headspace launch free preChaos at Twitter as Elon Musk throws employees under the bus to appease rightA fly landed on Mike Pence's head during the debate and it stayed there for 2 minutesKamala Harris reminding Mike Pence 'I'm speaking' is every woman in a meeting(Topical) Poem of the Day by Sadie SteinUrban Renewal: An Interview with Adrian Tomine by Peter TerzianGoogle Wallet is making it easier to save passes, IDs and moreGroup chats are the ideal way to process the Trump COVID news (and the rest of 2020)'Black Mirror' Season 6 trailer: All the Easter eggs you may have missedAI meets healthcare: How a children's hospital is embracing innovationIntroducing the Paris Review App! by The Paris ReviewPresident Trump taken to Walter Reed Medical Center after COVID Ludacris has ridiculously fake CGI abs in his new music video Motorola Razr first impression: About that crease... Rogue deer tackles innocent man in a parking lot Chris Pratt singing to his 'cheat meal' scones is all of us How ‘No Time to Die’ could evolve the concept of the 'Bond girl' The particular anxiety of packing for a date How they compare: Samsung Galaxy S20 vs. iPhone 11 Pro Ken Jeong on his ‘breakthrough role’ in ‘The Office’ and Steve Carell's genius WhatsApp has more than 2 billion users 5 reasons why Samsung's Galaxy Z Flip might not be a disaster like the Fold 7 women to honor this International Day of Women and Girls in Science Horse with a hipster mustache is definitely judging you 8 Twitter improvements that could actually help out Facebook is experimenting with a Pinterest Trump tweets a 'Curb Your Enthusiasm' clip that's clearly mocking him Xiaomi Mi 10 Pro is basically a cheaper Samsung Galaxy S20 Plus This 'Simpsons' quote was looped for 4 hours by a TV station and it will melt your brain 'Love Is Blind' review Hands on with the Galaxy Buds+: The AirPods Pro have some competition Hulu's 'High Fidelity' offers an updated look at heartbreak: Review
2.2807s , 10133.6484375 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Watch Kalakal Online】,Defense Information Network